Ask a Question
Notify Me On Question Update
Email this Question
How safe are home canned quick breads?
Rate This FAQ
Banana nut bread, zucchini bread or similar products should be either eaten fresh or frozen immediately. DON’T CAN THEM AND DON’T EAT THEM IF SOMEONE GIVES YOU THESE HOME CANNED PRODUCTS!
Bottled or canned quick breads are popular gifts and periodically instructions are printed on how to can breads. Here’s why such products are unsafe:
* Products such as zucchini bread are baked in wide-rimmed canning jars and covered with lids and rings immediately after removal from the oven. As the mixture cools, a vacuum seal is formed. The product has the potential to cause botulism poisoning and kill or seriously impair the person eating the bread.
* botulinum is found in soil throughout the world. The cleaning and processing of the ingredients that are used in bread would decrease its likelihood of being present, but by no means insure that it is not present. For example, it could be introduced into the batter in honey, on grated zucchini or dust in the mixing bowl. The organism C. botulinum itself is harmless; however, when conditions are right, it can form an extremely potent toxin.
* There are three factors that determine if C. botulinum will grow or not: a nonacid pH, moisture and an airless environment. Sealing the bread in a jar provides the necessary airless condition. A widely distributed recipe for canning zucchini bread has a 45 minute baking time at 325°F. The baking of the bread does not kill the C. botulinum. It is a spore forming organism and spores are resistant to destruction by heat or other environmental factors.
* Although no reported cases of botulism have been identified as being caused specifically by a home canned quick bread, the potential is there. The product meets all the necessary criteria for the organism to grow.
We have conducted research at Utah State University to see if it was possible to either raise or lower the acid level enough to control C. botulinum or add enough sugar to control water activity (the amount of moisture available to the microorganism) while still having a palatable zucchini bread. We were unable to formulate a safe product.
Submit Your Suggestion
Other Questions In This Topic
- I am going out of the country for a few years and will be unable to purchase powdered sugar and also tomato paste where I will be living. Is there a way I can make these things myself using very basic products?
- I baked a German Chocolate cake yesterday that after baking and cooling slightly, you poke holes and put sweetened condensed milk in the holes, then you put a jar of butterscotch caramel topping on. I forgot to put it in the refrigerator before going to bed. Is is okay to eat? It doesn't have the Cool Whip on top yet.
- I made an apple pumpkin butter and processed it as instructed for 10 minutes in a water bath. There are air bubbles that appeared after processing. The lids have sealed and there were no other problems. Should it still be safe to store and eat?
- I live in Provo Canyon and want a peach tree that grows big, wonderful, juicy, beautiful peaches (not so much for canning but for deserts). Do you have a recommendation?
- My turkey brining recipe calls for 4 juniper berries crushed in the brine. Can I use the berries from my yard shrubs for this purpose?
- Do you have information on freezer meals?
- I have a recipe for chili sauce that has tomatoes, onion, sugar, and spices. After it has cooked down, I just put it in hot jars and put the canning lids on. Is that okay, or do I need to process in a boiling water bath?
- I was eating a pear when I noticed a small white worm about 1/4 of an inch long with a black dot on the end or head of it . Am I going to get sick? I was able to see one but not sure if there were 2 and maybe I ate one. What should I do?