Ask a Question
Notify Me On Question Update
Email this Question
I am trying to find an organic solution to spraying weeds in the vegetable garden, such as morning glory. Would a mix of vinegar and lemon juice spread to the roots of the vegetables also, or could it be used? If so, do you have any information on proportions for the mix?
Rate This FAQ
Sadly there are very few good organic herbicides for perennial, persistent and quite annoying weeds like field bind weed. Even our best chemical herbicides will not completely control this aggressive invader.
However, there are some organic herbicides on the market that have the “burn back” characteristics of the chemical glyphosate (trade name Round-up and others). These include organic herbicides like AllDown (citric acid (5%), garlic (0.2%), acetic acid, yucca extracts, water (94.8%)), Matran 2 (clove oil (33.7%) and acetic acid), Xpress (thyme oil (10.4%), clove oil (10.1%), acetic acid, molasses, water (79.5%)), or Nature’s Avenger (natural citrus oil based non-selective herbicide). Each contains various combinations of natural oils or acids. As you can see some of these say that they have acetic acid (vinegar) in them but say nothing about the strength of that vinegar or what percent of the solutions are vinegar or water. Most of the organic chemicals (trade names) are available on the internet.
In some work done by the Sustainable Agricultural Systems Laboratory (part of the US Dept of Agriculture) on using vinegar as a herbicide, they showed that vinegar can kill several important weed species at several growth stages. Vinegar at 10%, 15% or 20% acetic acid concentration provided 80-100 percent kill of selected annual weeds, including giant foxtail up to 3 inches in height, common lambsquarters up to 5 inches, smooth pigweed up to 6 inches, and velvetleaf up to 9 inches. Control of annual weeds with vinegar at the 5% acetic acid concentration (most products sold in grocery stores contain 5% acetic acid) was variable. Canada thistle shoots were highly susceptible with 100 percent kill by 5% vinegar, however, there was re-growth from roots. Sadly, established perennial weeds (like bindweed) usually will not be killed by vinegar. Even under repeated applications to the growing tissue, they still came back.
One needs to be very careful with concentrated acetic acid as it does burn and can injure the user if you get it on your skin or in your eyes or throat (inhale it). So watch out if you decide to use it. You can try and make your own but unless you get the concentration of the acids up to high levels, they are not that effective.
You also need to remember that these are contact herbicides and will damage any green tissue they come into contact with. So if you are using them in the vegetable garden, they will “burn back” the vegetable as well as the weeds. So be extra careful.
Hope this helps.
Submit Your Suggestion
Other Questions In This Topic
- I am considering a weeping willow for my back yard. I have not heard good things about them being planted in Salt Lake. What is your opinion, and would I be better going with a different species or will a willow be fine?
- I have small white worms in my turnips and radishes. How do I deal with this problem?
- A landscaping company planted 6 jaquemonti birch in my yard at the end of May. Two of them recently began developing darkish brown leaf spots in the center. They are getting plenty of water. On one of the leaves I found very tiny black insects. I did not find insects on any of the other leaves. What could the problem be and what should I do about it. I picked the infected leaves off that I could reach. I also collected the insects.
- Please suggest some good bush rose varieties (not reds)- 3-4'high and 4' wide for a border planting in front of my home. I live in Holladay. Also, will a variegated dogwood tree grow well here if not in full sun?
- We tilled our garden and planted peas and lettuce about three weeks ago. Nothing has come up yet. We were talking to our neighbor yesterday, and he told us that about 30-40 years ago, in a fit of vexation, the former owner spread an industrial strength soil sterilizing chemical on the area in which we planted our garden. He further explained that weeds have only started to grow in that area in the past 5-10 years. This information has caused my wife to give up on trying to cultivate this area. Should we give up? What can we do to amend the soil in this area?
- I live in East Murray, West Holaday, Salt Lake County. We have a large pine tree and want to plant some flowers under/near it. The plants would be along a fence that runs to the east of the tree. Some, very little west sun in the evening. Any suggestions? I would love some long lasting flowers.
- I have some fruit trees in a lawn area that I have been fertilizing with ammonium sulfate, but needed to change to a weed & feed. Is the fruit still safe to eat?
- I have recently had topsoil brought in to grow a garden and my vegetable plants are wilting as if something in the soil is affecting them how do I get my soil tested to correct this?