Ask a Question
Notify Me On Question Update
Email this Question
I am trying to find an organic solution to spraying weeds in the vegetable garden, such as morning glory. Would a mix of vinegar and lemon juice spread to the roots of the vegetables also, or could it be used? If so, do you have any information on proportions for the mix?
Rate This FAQ
Sadly there are very few good organic herbicides for perennial, persistent and quite annoying weeds like field bind weed. Even our best chemical herbicides will not completely control this aggressive invader.
However, there are some organic herbicides on the market that have the “burn back” characteristics of the chemical glyphosate (trade name Round-up and others). These include organic herbicides like AllDown (citric acid (5%), garlic (0.2%), acetic acid, yucca extracts, water (94.8%)), Matran 2 (clove oil (33.7%) and acetic acid), Xpress (thyme oil (10.4%), clove oil (10.1%), acetic acid, molasses, water (79.5%)), or Nature’s Avenger (natural citrus oil based non-selective herbicide). Each contains various combinations of natural oils or acids. As you can see some of these say that they have acetic acid (vinegar) in them but say nothing about the strength of that vinegar or what percent of the solutions are vinegar or water. Most of the organic chemicals (trade names) are available on the internet.
In some work done by the Sustainable Agricultural Systems Laboratory (part of the US Dept of Agriculture) on using vinegar as a herbicide, they showed that vinegar can kill several important weed species at several growth stages. Vinegar at 10%, 15% or 20% acetic acid concentration provided 80-100 percent kill of selected annual weeds, including giant foxtail up to 3 inches in height, common lambsquarters up to 5 inches, smooth pigweed up to 6 inches, and velvetleaf up to 9 inches. Control of annual weeds with vinegar at the 5% acetic acid concentration (most products sold in grocery stores contain 5% acetic acid) was variable. Canada thistle shoots were highly susceptible with 100 percent kill by 5% vinegar, however, there was re-growth from roots. Sadly, established perennial weeds (like bindweed) usually will not be killed by vinegar. Even under repeated applications to the growing tissue, they still came back.
One needs to be very careful with concentrated acetic acid as it does burn and can injure the user if you get it on your skin or in your eyes or throat (inhale it). So watch out if you decide to use it. You can try and make your own but unless you get the concentration of the acids up to high levels, they are not that effective.
You also need to remember that these are contact herbicides and will damage any green tissue they come into contact with. So if you are using them in the vegetable garden, they will “burn back” the vegetable as well as the weeds. So be extra careful.
Hope this helps.
Submit Your Suggestion
Other Questions In This Topic
- I am a landscape designer and have a client in Hyrum with an orchard of about 25 misc. fruit trees. Of course the clients want low maintenance. What is a good way to control weeds in the orchard? Turf? Bare soil and cultivation? Bark mulch? If turf is a good option, what variety? Thanks.
- I had three Canadian Red Chokecherry (prunus virginiana L.) planted Oct 2007; 1 1/2" caliper, 13' tall. This spring, the leaves were a solid green; now they they are turning a purplish red. Is this normal?
- My husband mistakenly put fertilizer with a broad leaf killer in it on our garden. Is there anything we can do to grow things this year? Everything has died sadly.
- This year a majority of our tomatoes have brown spots on the bottom. Some of them as soon as they are ripe they have mold growing on them. Are these safe to eat an can or what do I need to do. We have about 8 or 9 plants. They are not producing that well. It seems to be on all of are tomatoes except for the grape. What can we do to get this problem taken care of?
- I would like to prune my lilac bush. What is the best time of year to do so and how much can be cut back and not harm the bush?
- This year we planted our first home garden. It was a lot of fun, but we need to know what to do to make it better next year. Specifically: our plants grew VERY large, but did not yield much fruit. What fruit we did get was typically small and misshapen. We did not fertilize, except some nitrogen along with dead lawn clippings last fall. What should we do this fall to get the soils ready for more fruit and less leaves next year?
- We would like to remove the lawn from a large area around some 40-50 ft pine trees and cover the area with decorative bark. The roots are close enough to the surface in some areas that using a sod cutter would damage the trees. Would it work to just spray the grass with a killer, such as Roundup, and then put the bark directly on the dead grass? Would this affect the trees in the areas of the partially exposed roots? Any other suggestions?
- Now that it's August, how often should we water our lawn (rock/clay soil); for how long; when (late pm early am); and when do we NOT water? My husband waters every day separate areas (front one day; back the next = X3/week), for approx. 35 min. each station. I say this is TOO much water(ing).